Appendix: "Radiohalos in Coalified Wood"
Reprinted from
15 October 1976, Volume 194, pp. 315-318
|
SCIENCE
|
Radiohalos in Coalified Wood: New Evidence Relating to
the Time of Uranium Introduction and Coalification
Robert V. Gentry, Warner H. Christie, David H. Smith, J. F. Emery
S. A. Reynolds, Raymond Walker, S. S. Cristy and P. A. Gentry
Copyright © 1976 by the American Association for the Advancement of Science
Abstract. The discovery of embryonic halos around uranium-rich sites that exhibit very
high 238U/206Pb ratios suggests that uranium introduction may have occurred far more
recently than previously supposed. The discovery of 210Po halos derived from uranium
daughters, some elliptical in shape, further suggests that uranium-daughter infiltration
occurred prior to coalification when the radionuclide transport rate was relatively high and
the matrix still plastically deformable.
Even though the biological fossil record
has been extensively documented, the rather
abundant fossil record of radiohalos that exists
in the coalified wood from the Colorado
Plateau has remained virtually undeciphered.
Jedwab (1) and Breger (2) have determined
some important characteristics of such halos; in
fact, earlier (1, 2) as well as present investigations
on these samples (3) agree that: (i) the
microscopic-size radiocenters responsible for
halos (Fig. 1a) in coalified wood are actually
secondary sites that preferentially accumulated
α-radioactivity during an earlier period of earth
history when uranium-bearing solutions
infiltrated the logs after they had been
uprooted; (ii) although autoradiography shows
some α-activity dispersed throughout the
matrix (1, 2), most of it is still concentrated in
the discrete halo radiocenters; (iii) variations in
coloration among radiohalos cannot necessarily
be attributed solely to differences in the α-dose
because there is evidence that the coalified
wood was earlier far more sensitive to α-radiation
than at present (1); (iv) halos that
appear most intensely colored in unpolarized
transmitted light also show evidence of
induration; that is, when polished thin sections
of coalified wood are viewed with reflected
light (Fig. 1b), such high α-dose halos exhibit
high reflectivity and pronounced relief; and (v)
some areas of coloration are of chemical rather
than radioactive origin (1).
In addition to the above verifications, the
studies reported here mark the first time that (i)
radii measurements have been made to
determine the type and stage of development of
halos in coalified substances and (ii) the
radiocenters of such halos have been analyzed
by modern analytical techniques. The discoveries
reported herein raise questions
relative to when U was introduced into the
wood, the duration required for coalification,
and the age of the geological formations.
Specifically, it was discovered that the
halos (Fig. 1a) surrounding the α-active sites
are typically embryonic, that is, they do not
generally exhibit the outer 214Po ring
characteristic of fully developed U halos in
minerals (4). Such underdeveloped halos
generally imply a low U concentration in the
radiocenter. However, electron microprobe
x-ray fluorescence (EMXRF) analyses (Fig.
2a) show many such radiocenters contain a
large amount of U with the amount of
daughter product Pb being generally too
small to detect by EMXRF techniques (Fig.
2a). Although we discuss below the application
of ion microprobe mass spectrometer
(IMMA) techniques (5) to the problem of quantitatively determining the
238U/206Pb ratios, two important points
deserve mention here: (i) if there was only a
one-time introduction of U into the wood (2),
these radiocenters date from that event unless
subsequent mobilization of U occurred, and
(ii) if U was introduced prior to coalification
(1), then the 238U/206Pb ratios in these
radiocenters also relate to the time of
coalification.
Fig. 1. (a) Coalified wood halos with U radiocenters in
transmitted light (× 125) [see (7)].
(b) The same halos in reflected light. The
bright central spot in each halo is the radiocenter (× 125)
|
Another class of more sharply defined
halos was discovered possessing smaller
inclusions ( 1 to 4 μm in diameter) than the
α-active sites. These inclusions exhibit a
distinct metallic-like reflectance when viewed
with reflected light. Three different varieties
of this halo exist: one with a circular cross
section, another with an elliptical cross
section with variable major and minor axes,
and a third most unusual one that is actually a
dual halo, being a composite of a circular and
an elliptical halo around exactly the same
radiocenter (see Fig. 3, a to c).
Although the elliptical halos differ radically
from the circular halos in minerals (6),
the circular type resembles the 210Po halo in
minerals and variations in the radii of circular
halos approximate the calculated penetration
distances ( 26 to 31 μm) of the 210Po
α-particle (energy Eα = 5.3 Mev) in this coalified
wood (7). Henderson (8) theorized that Po
halos might form in minerals when U-daughter
Po isotopes or their β-precursors
were preferentially accumulated into small inclusions
from some nearby U source. Although
this hypothesis was not confirmed for
U-poor minerals (9), it did seem a possibility
in this U-rich matrix.
The EMXRF analyses (Fig. 2b) showed
that the halo inclusions were mainly Pb and
Se. This composition fits well into the
secondary accumulation hypothesis for both
of the U-daughters, 210Po (half-life, t1/2 = 138
days) and its β-precursor 210Pb (t1/2 = 22
years), possess the two characteristics that are
vitally essential for the hypothesis: (i)
chemical similarity with the elements in the
inclusion and (ii) half-lives sufficiently long
to permit accumulation prior to decay. This
latter requirement is dependent on the
radionuclide transport rate. In minerals the
diffusion coefficients are so low that there is a
negligible probability that 210Po or 210Pb
atoms would migrate even 1 μm before
decaying, and thus the origin of Po halos in minerals is still being argued (6,
10).
|